Why there is no Obsidian web app
Obsidian is local-first on purpose: your vault is a folder of Markdown files on your machine, and the app that reads it runs on that machine. Obsidian Sync keeps an encrypted copy so several devices stay in step, and Obsidian Publish puts a read-only copy of chosen notes on the web, but neither is a cloud workspace you can open in a browser. That design is also why hosted assistants struggle with it: Claude on the web or your phone has no way to open files on your laptop, so AI access means wiring up plugins or a local MCP server and keeping the machine that holds the vault switched on.
What moving to the cloud actually buys you
A hosted vault turns "my notes" from a folder on one machine into an endpoint everything you use can reach. In Hjarni that means a web app in any browser, iOS and Android apps, and a built-in MCP server that Claude and ChatGPT connect to with a one-time OAuth approval: no plugins, no machine left running at home. Ask Claude to save a note from your phone, refine it later from a browser at work, and both touch the same Markdown. Folder-level AI instructions and shared team folders come with it, which a folder of local files cannot do.
Keep the parts of Obsidian that matter
What people actually refuse to give up is rarely the local disk. It is plain Markdown, folders, and wiki-links. Those carry over. You import your vault as a ZIP and folders, wiki-links, front-matter, and attachments come across intact. And the exit stays open: export the entire knowledge base as a ZIP of Markdown files anytime, and drop it straight back into an Obsidian vault if the cloud turns out not to be for you. Hosted is a choice about where the files live, not about who owns them.
When to stay local
If you work offline, love the plugin ecosystem, lean on graph view or Dataview, or have a hard requirement that data stays on your own hardware, keep Obsidian: it is the best local vault there is, and self-hosting your AI memory is a legitimate choice. There is also a middle path: keep Obsidian as your local editor and sync Hjarni notes into your vault, so the cloud copy is what your AI reads while the vault stays your writing desk.
Sync moves your vault between your devices. The cloud takes it off your devices entirely, and puts it where your AI can reach it.